Categories
ESSENTIAL NEW MUSIC

Essential New Music: Tommy Keene’s “Songs From The Film: The 1984 Reflection Sessions”

For those unlucky souls who missed out on the vinyl on Record Store Day in April of this year, Songs From The Film: The 1984 Reflection Sessions—meant to be the late, great power-pop legend Tommy Keene’s sophomore effort—is now streaming. (Bandcamp purchasers can also get files via download.)

But doesn’t Keene’s discography already include a Songs From The Film, you ask? That’s correct. The shortish explanation is that the original LP, produced by T-Bone Burnette and Don Dixon and slated for Dolphin Records, was shelved thanks to the fine folks at Geffen, who wanted to sign Keene and requested (demanded) he keep it in the vault—or else kiss their interest goodbye. Seeing the major-label holy grail within his grasp, Keene acquiesced. Who could blame him? The upside is that the Geffen version of Songs, released in 1986, is fantastic (my favorite album of all time, but I digress); the downside is that Geffen pulled some shenanigans prior to 1989’s follow-up, Based On Happy Times, and dropped him soon after. The rest of Keene’s music-industry experience was checkered, to put it mildly.

For those keeping score, most of the tunes on The Reflection Sessions have been previously available: “Away From It All,” “Back Again,” “I Don’t Feel Right At All,” “Run Now” and “They’re In Their Own World” were found on 1986’s Run Now EP; “Faith In Love” and “We’re Two” landed on the 1998 CD reissue of the Geffen Songs; and “Fall Down Too” was a bonus track from 2010’s Tommy Keene You Hear Me: A Retrospective 1983-2009.

Nerding out further: Of the tracks on The Reflection Sessions, re-recorded takes of only “Call On Me,” “Gold Town” and “The Story Ends” ended up on the 1986 LP, so this is essentially a different, yet wonderful, album. It fortunately lacks the Geffen version’s soon-to-be-dated production, and the drum sound is noticeably crisper. Even with some of the numbers already heard, it’s a revelation to listen to the full outing as Keene envisioned. Forty-plus years on, Keene’s melodic, razor-sharp songwriting has proven remarkably resistant to the passage of time.

What would’ve happened had Keene told Geffen to pound sand and released Songs From The Film as intended is obviously unknowable. Maybe another (competent) major would’ve come along, and Keene’s career would’ve turned out much differently. Ultimately, it’s best not to contemplate the what-ifs and just revel in the fact that The Reflection Sessions exists.

—Matt Hickey